Brumbaugh enters his second season as the Terriers' cornerback coach in 2025, having previously served as a five-year linebacker for Knox College (Division III | Galesburg, IL). Brumbaugh tallied 33 career games of action, which was highlighted by 128 tackles, 10 tackles for loss, and two interceptions, one of which was a pick-six this past season.
Brumbaugh is from Forsyth, Illinois and attended Warrensburg Latham High School.